1870 Mag

Thin Crust Dominates Top 5 Local Pizza Joints

Even bad pizza is good pizza but here is the best pizza in Columbus as chosen by our friends on Yelp.

#5  Rubino’s Pizza

2643 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209

✭✭✭✭ 157 Reviews

Chelsea E., Columbus, OH: “It’s a great, rich/hearty pizza sauce. I also like that the pepperonis are crispy ones. Delicious! To me, the best part about Rubino’s is the thin, flaky, almost cracker-like crust.”

#4 Borgata Pizza Cafe

5701 Parkville St
Columbus, OH 43229

✭✭✭✭+1/2 269 Reviews

Jorie F., Columbus, OH: “The crust is what sets it apart and makes me think of trips to Italy.  You can tell it’s fresh, never frozen…it’s got a nice small amount of rise while still being thin and a nice mix of chewy & crisp.”

#3 Harvest Pizzeria

495 S 4th St
Columbus, OH 43206

✭✭✭✭+1/2 335 Reviews

James N., Indianapolis, IN: “I got the White Pizza (added meatballs and red onion) and it was in the top 5 pizzas I’ve ever eaten.”

Note: Harvest Kitchen & Bar and Curio, which serves Harvest Pizzeria came in at #5 and #6 respectively. Harvest obviously dominated the list but to give other shops a shot, we decided to combine their rankings here in the #3 spot.

#2 Studio 35 Cinema & Drafthouse

3055 Indianola Ave
Columbus, OH 43202

✭✭✭✭+1/2 130 Reviews

Donna O., Columbus: “Another good reason to come early: the bar. Plenty of seating at the bar itself as well as perimeter tables, and they have happy hour specials for both drinks and pizza.”

#1 Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

7516 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

 ✭✭✭✭✭ 124 reviews

Jen. R, Pickerington: “Wow! Super impressed by this pizza. How have I never been here before? This is my new go-to pizza place…”

Regina Fox


The Giveaway!

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

The girl at the rpac wearing a camo shirt on the upstairs treadmill on Saturday, you looked amazing! Favorite this for a follow and dm!

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

The mouse I saw at K Comm t.co/B2CAIMx2hi

Show Media

Tweet Media

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

cute girl with the gray parka-ish coat at target. came up and asked if i’d seen any Stranger Things posters. i shou… t.co/SeAkJLqYg6

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

The super cute girl playing trombone at the men’s volleyball game last night. Wish I could have got your number!

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

the guy with a vest on at bulls on 12/13 that I danced with but i told him I had a boyfriend at first

Follow us

Don't be shy, get in touch. We love meeting interesting people and making new friends.