1870 Mag

Thin Crust Dominates Top 5 Local Pizza Joints

Even bad pizza is good pizza but here is the best pizza in Columbus as chosen by our friends on Yelp.

#5  Rubino’s Pizza

2643 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209

✭✭✭✭ 157 Reviews

Chelsea E., Columbus, OH: “It’s a great, rich/hearty pizza sauce. I also like that the pepperonis are crispy ones. Delicious! To me, the best part about Rubino’s is the thin, flaky, almost cracker-like crust.”

#4 Borgata Pizza Cafe

5701 Parkville St
Columbus, OH 43229

✭✭✭✭+1/2 269 Reviews

Jorie F., Columbus, OH: “The crust is what sets it apart and makes me think of trips to Italy.  You can tell it’s fresh, never frozen…it’s got a nice small amount of rise while still being thin and a nice mix of chewy & crisp.”

#3 Harvest Pizzeria

495 S 4th St
Columbus, OH 43206

✭✭✭✭+1/2 335 Reviews

James N., Indianapolis, IN: “I got the White Pizza (added meatballs and red onion) and it was in the top 5 pizzas I’ve ever eaten.”

Note: Harvest Kitchen & Bar and Curio, which serves Harvest Pizzeria came in at #5 and #6 respectively. Harvest obviously dominated the list but to give other shops a shot, we decided to combine their rankings here in the #3 spot.

#2 Studio 35 Cinema & Drafthouse

3055 Indianola Ave
Columbus, OH 43202

✭✭✭✭+1/2 130 Reviews

Donna O., Columbus: “Another good reason to come early: the bar. Plenty of seating at the bar itself as well as perimeter tables, and they have happy hour specials for both drinks and pizza.”

#1 Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

7516 E Main St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

 ✭✭✭✭✭ 124 reviews

Jen. R, Pickerington: “Wow! Super impressed by this pizza. How have I never been here before? This is my new go-to pizza place…”

Regina Fox


The Giveaway!

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

12th Avenue Bread Company for their music choices ❤❤❤

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

Cute woman who also likes women. So hard to find a girlfriend 🙁

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

The guy on the end of painted kids in Block o north. I know you have a girlfriend, but I’d gladly wreck your home

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

Anyone who can make me not want to call my ex at 1am every night

OSU Crush's Twitter avatar

OSU Crush

So sorry to the boy I slept with last night….turns out I have strep throat #whoopsies

Follow us

Don't be shy, get in touch. We love meeting interesting people and making new friends.